Price: $26
This formula is definitely thicker than the gel formula and is suited for those with dry skin. I usually only need 1-2 pumps to moisturize my whole face so little goes a long way. Clinque claims that it "helps strengthens skin's own moisture barrier by 54%, so more moisture stays in." After using it for couple of months now, I can attest to that statement. I use this during the colder months and the gel formula for warmer months. It keeps my skin hydrated from the moment I put it on to the moment I wash it off at night. It doesn't leave my face feeling oily/greasy, like many moisturizers formulated for dry skin. I think one thing to watch out for is that Clinque is known to use harsh chemicals, which could irritate the skin. I've, personally, never encountered this problem. I gave it a 4 out of 5 rather than a perfect score because I didn't really like the scent.
Price: $26
This is my go-to moisturizer. It's lightweight and leaves your skin super soft and smooth. Compared to the lotion+ formula, gel is a lot lighter because it's more water-based. I like this better because, weight-wise, I feel like I'm not wearing anything on my face. I leaves my skin feeling hydrated and soft and little goes a long way for this too. I just use 2 pumps to cover my entire face. I never made me break out. Bottom line - I love it.
< it basically looks the same but the gel is more translucent >